Michael Elphicke (right) may have to appear in court for his verdict over a video conference from a hospital bed, where he has had a foot amputated due to an infection. (Dustin Godfrey/Western News)

Alleged hockey fraudster could face justice over Skype

In hospital with health complications from kidney failure, Elphicke may hear his verdict over video

The defendant in a high-profile Penticton fraud case may have to receive his verdict over Facetime in a hospital bed.

Michael Elphicke, one of two men charged with fraud and theft over $5,000 and unauthorized operation of a lottery scheme, has been in declining health since around 2011, on dialysis due to kidney failure.

Since his trial ended late in September, Elphicke has reportedly gone to hospital with an infection in his foot, and defence lawyer James Pennington said on Thursday part of his foot has since been amputated.

Related: Elphicke reportedly took $17,000 of hockey funds

Elphicke’s toes and the ball of his left foot were reportedly removed to stop the infection in its tracks, and doctors believe it was successful — but it will still be a few days until doctors are sure of it.

“I contacted my learned friend from the Crown to give him a heads up as to what was going on,” Pennington told the court, adding both parties thought it best to put the matter before the judge.

Because he is in an Alberta hospital, and there may be some requirement that he stay in the hospital to ensure his infection has not spread and to undergo rehabilitation, he may not be able to make the court date for the verdict.

The Criminal Code of Canada mandates that the defendant be capable of visual and audio communication during a trial and verdict. It’s not unusual for defendants to appear by video conferencing in provincial jails where they are too distant to make the trip to the courthouse.

Related: Elphicke painting Penticton hockey fraud as one-man scam

But while that infrastructure is commonplace, lawyers and the justice overseeing the matters were faced with finding a way to make it happen in Elphicke’s circumstance.

“The video equipment could be brought to them, depending on their location, and set up. I’ve dealt with that a least a couple of times in my brief experience with the Crown,” said lawyer Patrick Fullerton, suggesting either video conferencing through a local court near Elphicke’s current location or a video calling app such as Facetime or Skype.

“I have heard of Facetime. That’s as far as my familiarity goes with it,” Pennington responded, adding he was interested in considering it.

Justice Gary Weatherill suggested that there could be a concern that Elphicke might not be alert, if he is on painkillers or other medications.

Related: Alleged hockey fraudster ‘embarrassed’ widow

Because of questions over the practicality of a video call with Elphicke in his hospital bed, lawyers will reconvene next week to determine the viability of that option.

Lawyers also addressed the issue of a Charter of Rights and Freedoms application on the case, with respect to the R. v Jordan ruling from 2016, which set a specific length of time a defendant can go between when charges are sworn and when a trial ends.

For superior court cases, such as Elphicke’s, that limit is 30 months, set as the reasonable length by the Supreme Court of Canada, whereas Elphicke’s case has run for upward of 32 months.

But it’s unclear whether enough delays occurred as a result of the defence, as to offset the excess trial length enough to keep the trial within Jordan’s parameters. As a result, Pennington has requested transcripts of previous meetings to try to determine that, but with a late application, those transcripts are still in the works.

Related: Elphicke could go free on time-to-trial rule

Fullerton argued that because Pennington knew of the trial length when dates were set last October, he had issues with the Charter application coming up at the end of this September.

But Weatherill countered that if a Charter application is made, it should be heard, adding the application can be debated after the verdict is settled, if the transcripts do not arrive in time.

Because Weatherill is retiring from the bench as of Nov. 24, he added a different justice may oversee the Jordan application and, if Elphicke is convicted, sentencing.

Related: Justice ministers across Canada meet to tackle delays in the courts


@dustinrgodfrey

dustin.godfrey@pentictonwesternnews.com

Like us on Facebook and follow us on Twitter.

Just Posted

Charges for the attempted murder of an Oliver man dropped

Afshin Maleki Ighani was accused of shooting an Oliver man in April.

Minor chlorine leak at Penticton water treatment plant

Emergency responders are at the Penticton water treatment plant

Former Penticton Pinnacles Football coach sues club

Ezra Cremers is suing the Pinnacles Football Club for wrongful dismissal and breach of contract

Holiday changes for curbside pickup

The RDOS is rescheduling some pickups around the holidays

Wintry weather to roll into Southern Interior

The Southern Interior is expected to get a snowstorm followed by freezing temperatures.

Santa’s helpers take treats to an Okanagan retirement home

Santa’s Little Helpers surprised an Okanagan retirement home with chocolates, flowers and cupcakes.

UPDATE: Grizzly bear trophy hunting over in B.C.

Now only Indigenous people can hunt bears for meat

Star Blue Jays announced for Vancouver ‘Winter Tour’ event in January

Toronto’s pro baseball team heads west for two-day event

Mental effects of wildfire still linger in Fort McMurray

‘Resilient, but tired:’ Mental effects of wildfire lingering in Fort McMurray

Climate change hits Winter Olympic preparation

AP Exclusive: Climate change hits Winter Olympic preparation

Calgary Flames thump Vancouver Canucks 6-1

Mark Giordano, Sam Bennett lead the way as Flames thump Canucks 6-1

Homicide detectives now probing billionaire couple’s death

Police release cause of death of Barry and Honey Sherman as “ligature neck compression”

‘Case not made’ for Liberal bill’s problematic cyberspy powers

The Liberal government’s ill-defined plan to give Canada’s cyberspy agency wide-ranging powers to go on the attack against threats could trample civil liberties

Most Read