Convicted killer loses appeal

An appeal has been dismissed for convicted killer Dustin Paul, who shot five men on the Penticton Indian Band reserve in 2004.

An appeal has been dismissed for convicted killer Dustin Paul, who shot five men on the Penticton Indian Band reserve in 2004.

Paul was found guilty by a 12-member jury of three second-degree murder charges in the deaths of Robin Baptiste, Damien Endreny and his cousin Quincy Paul. He admitted shooting them on Oct. 30, 2004 at a popular party spot on the Penticton Indian Band reserve.

Paul was also found guilty of the attempted murder of Tommy Lee Gabriel and Billy Louie, who suffered serious wounds in the shooting which happened after the men, including Paul, had consumed large amounts of cocaine, marijuana and alcohol.

Counsel for Paul argued trial judge, Justice Duncan Shaw, did not satisfactorily explain to the jury the mental capacity required for criminal responsibility.

In the appeal court decision made on Friday, Paul’s counsel noted he experienced a “temporary psychotic break” brought on by the ingestion of alcohol and drugs, and the judge erred in not putting the defence of not criminally responsible by reason of mental disorder to the jury. Counsel said Paul interpreted a hallucination to mean that it was time that he “woke up” by dying and going to a better place.

“He understood that he would not have to be in the better place alone, and for that reason shot the five men to take them to that better place with him. On this appeal, counsel for the defence submits that the evidence in this case takes the appellant into an unsettled area of criminal responsibility,” states the decision.

The appeal court found that disease of the mind excludes self-induced states caused by alcohol or drugs. The court concluded that Paul’s condition was self-induced and he knew he was trying to kill people.

The second complaint arose over the concepts of intent and motive. At trial Paul testified he heard voices telling him to go to a better place to be awakened. Paul said he did not want to go alone and the voice told him he would be able to “wake up with all these people.” Using a Supreme Court of Canada decision, it was explained motive is no part of the crime and is legally irrelevant to criminal responsibility.

Appeal court judges also rejected the grounds of appeal on arguments brought forward by Paul’s counsel suggesting the trial judge made an error in telling the jury a new trial would be ordered in the event they were not able to agree on a verdict, that the trial judge made an error in giving the jury inadequate instructions on the need to consider each count individually, and that the trail judge erred in failing to tell the jury that they might find Paul guilty on the lesser included offences if they could not agree on a verdict on the full charge.

In April of 2007, Paul was sentenced to life in prison with no chance of parole for 16 years.

Just Posted

Skeena MLA Ellis Ross. (Photo by Peter Versteege)
BC Liberal leadership candidate condemns ‘senseless violence’ of Okanagan church fires

Skeena MLA Ellis Ross says reconciliation isn’t about revenge for past tragedies

( photo)
No COVID-19 baby boom in Summerland

Pandemic has not resulted in surge in births in 2020 and 2021

(Black Press file photo)
EDITORIAL: Curtailing attempts at scams

The true total of losses from all scams and frauds could be much higher than the figures on file

Penticton Indian Band Chief Greg Gabriel speaks to the Sacred Hearts Catholic Church burning down early Monday morning, June 21, 2021. (Monique Tamminga Western News)
Penticton band chief condemns suspicious burning of 2 Catholic churches

Both Catholic church fires are deemed suspicious, says RCMP

(Drive BC photo)
Vehicle incident closes Highway 3 east of Osoyoos

Drive BC says to avoid the area until the road is clear

The border crossing into the United States is seen during the COVID-19 pandemic in Lacolle, Que. on February 12, 2021. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Paul Chiasson
VIDEO: Border quarantine to soon lift for fully vaccinated Canadians

Eligible travellers must still take multiple COVID-19 tests

Paul Bernardo is shown in this courtroom sketch during Ontario court proceedings via video link in Napanee, Ont., on October 5, 2018. Teen killer and serial rapist Paul Bernardo is set for a parole hearing today. The designated dangerous offender, has been eligible for full parole for more than three years. Bernardo’s horrific crimes in the 1980s and early 1990s include for kidnapping, torturing and killing Kristen French and Leslie Mahaffy near St. Catharines, Ont. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Greg Banning
Killer rapist Paul Bernardo faces parole hearing today; victim families opposed

Designated dangerous offender has been eligible for full parole for more than three years.

People look over the damage after a tornado touched down in Mascouche, Que., north of Montreal, Monday, June 21, 2021. Dozens of homes were damaged and one death has been confirmed. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Ryan Remiorz
One dead and extensive damage as tornado hits Mascouche, Que., north of Montreal

Damage reported in several parts of the city, and emergency teams dispatched to sectors hardest hit

Chilliwack secondary school’s principal is apologizing after a quote equating graduation with the end of slavery in the U.S. was included in the 2020-2021 yearbook. (Screenshot from submitted SnapChat)
B.C. student’s yearbook quote equates grad to end of slavery; principal cites editing error

Black former student ‘disgusted’ as CSS principal apologizes for what is called an editing error

A coroner’s inquest will be taking place at the Capitol Theatre in Port Alberni for the next week. (ELENA RARDON / ALBERNI VALLEY NEWS)
Teen B.C. mom who died following police custody recalled as ‘friend to many’

Police sent Jocelyn George to hospital after intoxication had gone ‘beyond the realm’ of normal detox

FILE - In this Nov. 29, 2020, file photo, Las Vegas Raiders defensive end Carl Nassib leaves the field after an NFL football game against the Atlanta Falcons in Atlanta. Nassib on Monday, June 21, 2021, became the first active NFL player to come out as gay. Nassib announced the news on Instagram, saying he was not doing it for the attention but because “I just think that representation and visibility are so important.” (AP Photo/John Bazemore, File)
Nassib becomes first active NFL player to come out as gay

More than a dozen NFL players have come out as gay after their careers were over

Former Kamloops security gaurd wants job back after kicking incident caught on video

Rick Eldridge quit when a video surfaced of him kicking a man outside a facility for homeless

People participated in a walk to honour the 215 children found at a former Kamloops residential school, as well as residential school survivors. (Twila Amato/Black Press Media)
Kelowna marks National Indigenous Peoples’ Day with walk to remember Kamloops 215

“Let’s speak the truth and deal with the truth, and heal.”

COVID-19 daily cases reported to B.C. public health, seven-day moving average to June 17, 2021. (B.C. Centre for Disease Control)
B.C.’s COVID-19 infections drop to 90 on Sunday, 45 Monday

Pandemic spread dwindles as 77% of adults receive vaccine

Most Read