Paramjit Singh Bogarh pleaded guilty on March 5, 2020 to assisting in the escape of his brother, found guilty of murdering Paramjit’s wife in 1986. (File photo)

Imprisoned Okanagan man has claustrophobia complaint rejected

Paramjit Bogarh’s complaint was dismissed by the B.C. Human Rights Tribunal April 15

The B.C. Human Rights Tribunal has rejected the complaint of an incarcerated Vernon man, who alleged he was transferred within the prison system inhumanely given his claustrophobia.

Paramjit Bogarh, 59, was sentenced to five years in prison March 5, 2020, after pleading guilty to accessory to murder after the fact. Bogarh’s wife, Saminder Kaur Bogarh, was the murder victim while Bogarh’s own brother, Narinder Bogarh, is wanted for her murder. Narinder is reportedly at large in India.

Bogarh filed a complaint against the B.C. prison system on Nov. 19, 2019, alleging discrimination in prison services based on his age and physical and mental disabilities, in violation of section 8 of the Human Rights Code.

The B.C. Human Rights Tribunal rejected Bogarh’s complaint April 15 because he failed to file the complaint within the allowed period of time.

“The issue before me with respect to timeliness is whether to accept the complaint against the Respondents for filing, and I make no findings of fact regarding the merits of this complaint,” said Tribunal member Steven Adamson in his decision.

According to the decision, Bogarh reported having prostate issues, anxiety and claustrophobia, all of which were unaccomodated during two transfers while in custody in mid-2018.

Bogarh’s complaint alleged that on July 17 of that year he was transferred from a correctional facility in the Okanagan to the Surrey Pretrial Services Centre in a small and confined space, triggering his claustrophobia.

Bogarh said he experienced panic attacks as well as an urgency to urinate due to his prostate issues.

“Without washroom stops on the long journey, he reports being left in severe pain while fearing he would urinate himself. Mr. Bogarh states he worried about losing his dignity if that occurred along with the threat of violence from the other inmates that would come with such an incident.”

On Aug. 2, 2018, Bogarh said he was taken to court in similar fashion to the July incident.

Under Section 22 of the Human Rights Code, complaints must be submitted within one year of the incident in question. That deadline can be waived in cases where doing so is in the public interest, but the tribunal chose not to make an exception.

“Mr. Bogarh has provided no reasonable explanation for why he waited so long to file his complaint about events that occurred in 2018. Rather, it points to his interest in not being transported in the same way again,” Adamson said. “That strategic consideration, without more, does not engage the public interest in filing a late‐filed complaint.”

Adamson said Bogarh did not make a reply submission, though he had the opportunity to do so.

Bogarh had three years credit for time in custody at the time of his sentencing in March, meaning he has close to two years in prison remaining.

READ MORE: Nova Scotia gunman acquired police car last fall at auction: RCMP

READ MORE: Victim’s son speaks about Shuswap church shooting on first anniversary


Brendan Shykora
Reporter, Vernon Morning Star
Email me at Brendan.Shykora@vernonmorningstar.com
Follow us: Facebook | Twitter

CourtCrime

Get local stories you won't find anywhere else right to your inbox.
Sign up here

Just Posted

COVID-19 closes Okanagan College summer camps

Popular Camp OC put on shelf from Salmon Arm to Penticton, and Revelstoke, until 2021

Reports of early morning gunshots rattle downtown Penticton

Three to four gunshot like sounds were reported by residents

COVID-19: SD67 approves budget reductions

Staff positions will be cut to balance budget

COVID-19: Pre-recorded graduation events planned for students in School District 67

Graduates from Penticton Secondary have created petition to urge postponement of grad ceremonies

COVID-19: SD67 plans restart program for Penticton, Summerland students

District following provincial guidelines as students return to classrooms on June 1

Video: Okanagan mayors encourage water conservation this summer

Water conservation this summer could be more important than ever, experts say

B.C. mom’s drug-pricing petition on behalf of son garners thousands of signatures

Petition geared to gaining access to new medicines drew support of Chilliwack-Hope MP Mark Strahl

Body of missing woman found in Kelowna

Kelly Joy Zuchotzki was last seen on May 24

‘Paralyzed by fear’: B.C. woman details anxiety, grief at Italian relief hospital

Sheila Vicic spent two months in Italy as the country grappled with COVID-19

Dr. Bonnie Henry given new name in B.C. First Nation ceremony: ‘one who is calm among us’

The provincial health officer was honoured in a May 22 ceremony at elementary school in Hazelton

Almost half of shops in North Okanagan mall reopened

Reduced food court capacity, curb-side pickup program en route

CAMH survey looks at binge-drinking, financial anxiety during COVID

Alcohol may be used as a coping mechanism for those whose careers may have been sidelined due to the pandemic

Half of Canadians say governments are hiding something about COVID-19: poll

More than a third of people believe the virus was created in a lab

Morning Start: Why is it so dangerous to wake a sleepwalker?

Your morning start for Tuesday, May 26, 2020

Most Read