Andrea DeMeer Karl Gatzky outside the Princeton courthouse during a recess last October.

New trial ordered in Coalmont feud

Supreme Court faults key testimony

A man convicted last October of uttering threats against a Coalmont resident will get a new trial following a ruling from the BC Supreme Court.

Karl Gatzky’s conviction was overturned in a decision released Tuesday.

Because of a publication ban, the names of the alleged victim in the case, and any witnesses, cannot be identified.

According to the decision authored by Associate Chief Justice A.F. Cullen, the presiding judge made numerous errors when he established Gatzky’s guilt.

Gatzky is accused of threatening to shoot a Coalmont woman on April 2, 2015.

Related: Judge hopes Coalmont feud stops

The incident was described as part of an ongoing neighborhood dispute involving himself and his daughter Maryanne, and others in the tiny village.

The trial judge improperly ignored evidence given by Gatzky, the decision states.

Further, according to Cullen, too much weight was assigned to a key witness for the Crown who “did not display the characteristics of an impartial or careful witness.”

The trial judge called the witness “very important…He struck me as being a forthright, honest witness.”

Related: Little village has big problems

The appeal decision says this witness displayed antipathy towards the accused and sympathy for the alleged victim.

The witness claimed he heard Gatzky threaten to shoot the woman.

However the higher court found that his testimony at times contradicted the evidence of the complainant as well as evidence given to police.

“He was disrespectful to and argumentative with [Gatzky’s] counsel,” the decision reads.

The document indicates that at least twice this witness told defense counsel: “you’re full of it,” under cross-examination.

During the original trial Gatzky was acquitted of causing a disturbance, engaging in the threatening conduct and criminal harassment.

On the sole charge of uttering threats he was sentenced to two years probation and prohibited from going within 75 metres of the complainant’s house.

Just Posted

One of Ighani’s trials may move to Kelowna

The matter is complicated by the fact that two complainants and the accused are all in custody

Penticton firearms sentencing set for May

Cody J. E. Wilson was found guilty on all but one count in a firearms trial earlier this month

Two decades of volunteering recognized with Rotary Unsung Citizen Award

Penticton man receives Rotary Club of Penticton-Okanagan Unsung Citizen Award

Penticton Vees defeat Surrey Eagles to hold on to first place in BCHL

The Penticton Vees (38-12-2-3) scored twice in the opening three minutes of the third period

Curlers gearing up for the B.C. Games

Penticton and Summerland team prepping to compete at B.C. Winter Games

Happy ending to Tom Sawyer’s story

Happy ending to story of a cat left on the side of the road to die

Rules reviewed to keep drug money out of B.C. real estate

Investigator looking at loans as well as casinos, David Eby says

No charges for B.C. Mountie in car wash shooting

A report found the Salmon Arm officer fired 14 bullets at the man’s truck

Suspect faces charges of possession of stolen property, weapon

Two people arrested outside Shaw Centre in Salmon Arm Saturday, woman released without charge

How to keep local news visible in your Facebook feed

Facebook has changed the news feed to emphasize personal connections. You might see less news.

VIDEO: SUV races moose along Similkameen roadway

Moose pose highway danger, and they are pretty fast too

VIDEO: B.C. deer caught obeying traffic signs

A herd of deer in Fernie, B.C. is getting attention online after stopping for a stop sign

Petition wants fundraiser dropped for family of man cleared in Boushie’s death

Group says GoFundMe is profiting from the young Indigenous man’s death

Most Read