Osoyoos knife-wielding woman wins appeal to reduce sentence

Court of Appeal settled that the sentencing judge erred in principle, and the sentence was unfit

A South Okanagan woman convicted of threatening an Osoyoos mother and seven-week-old baby, while wielding a knife and trying to enter the home, won her appeal Tuesday for a reduced sentence.

The decision made in court cites that the sentencing judge erred in principle in a manner that impacted the sentence he imposed.

In August 2019, Sharon Forner pleaded guilty to one count of break and enter to commit an indictable offence and was sentenced to three years, four months and 11 days, less time served, plus three years probation. The probation order included a term that would banish her from Osoyoos.

The sentence stemmed from an incident on August 8, 2018, in which Forner appeared at the victim’s door visibly intoxicated, wearing a wig, and asked to see the victim’s baby. She then entered the victim’s home holding a large butcher knife. The incident ended when the victim successfully pushed Forner back outside.

Forner appealed the custodial portion of her 40-month sentence, as well as the banishment term in her probation order.

In a BC Court of Appeal decision published April 7, Forner’s custodial sentence was reduced to 20 months, and her banishment was removed.

Justice Christopher Grauer’s decision, which references Forner’s long history of depression and alcohol abuse disorder, cites that the sentence from Justice Gregory Koturbash ‘erred in principle’ by failing to treat Forner’s mental illness as a mitigating factor, and by ‘treating her addiction as significantly aggravating, where one contributed to the other and both contributed to the offence’.

Also, the decision by Grauer cites that Forner had no history of violence and no physical injury.

It also cites that the sentence was unfit, and the banishment term was unreasonable.

“The result was a disproportionate sentence that failed to take proper account of the impact of the appellant’s addiction and mental health issues on her moral culpability, as well as the absence of any history of violent acts,” said Grauer in his decision.

The decision further explains that this was an isolated event and that the sentence given did not facilitate the offender’s rehabilitation.

Grauer found that the non-contact terms of the order given adequately provide for the victim’s safety and security.

The Honourable Madam Justice Dickson and the Honourable Mr. Justice Abrioux agreed with Grauer’s decision.

READ MORE: RCMP pursuit in Okanagan Falls leads to arrest of Penticton man

READ MORE: Armed robbery of legal grow-op in Sicamous ends in arrest near Enderby


Get local stories you won't find anywhere else right to your inbox.
Sign up here

Just Posted

Penticton may soon allow drinking alcohol in some public places

Trying to inconspicuously drink on the beach could become a thing of the past

Dementia intensifies loneliness and loss for seniors in pandemic, says caregiver

Seniors care expert says patience and sharing keys to helping those with dementia cope through virus

No injuries in Penticton Indian Band structure fire

The structure, which sustained significant damage, was boarded up and seemingly vacant

B.C. legislature coming back June 22 as COVID-19 emergency hits record

Pandemic restrictions now longer than 2017 wildfire emergency

Houseboat company partly owned by Shuswap MLA withdraws controversial ad

The ad welcomed houseboaters from other provinces, contradicting anti COVID-19 measures.

Squabble between campers in North Shuswap leads to bear spraying

An argument over late night partying escalated into a fight which led to one person being sprayed

B.C.’s essential grocery, hardware store employees should get pandemic pay: retail group

Only B.C.’s social, health and corrections workers are eligible for top-ups

Edmonton, Vancouver and Toronto vying to be NHL hubs, but there’s a catch

The NHL unveiled a return-to-play plan that would feature 24 teams

B.C. sees 9 new COVID-19 cases, one death as officials watch for new cases amid Phase Two

Number of confirmed active cases is at 244, with 37 people in hospital

VIDEO: Flowers stolen from Vernon distillery

Okanagan Spirits Craft Distillery captured surveillance footage of the thief in a black car

Fundraiser launched for North Okanagan drive-in

Vernon resident seeks to raise $20K to save Starlight Drive-In

Unique ‘the Wedge’ development makes way back to Kelowna council

Council initially deferred its decision on the project in March

Most Read