More than 120,000 sandbags were laid down to protect Penticton beaches during the flooding crisis. The contract to remove them has been awarded to a company owned, in part, by Coun. Max Picton. Western News file photo

Penticton city councillor says no conflict

Coun. Max Picton said his company followed the rules bidding on a city contract

Max Picton said his position as a Penticton city councillor had no bearing on his construction company winning a valuable city contract.

Sun-Oak Construction, which Picton owns a 25 per cent share in, was awarded a contract for removal of 120,000 sandbags from Penticton beaches and low-lying areas. The contract is valued at about $187,000, plus $2.15 per bag for removal and disposal from private properties.

More: Penticton looking for help removing sandbags

Max Picton

The city posted a request for proposals in June and awarded the contract in mid-July. Picton gave official notice of his interest in the company on July 14.

“I didn’t have a contract to notify the city about until they awarded the contract, so I notified the city before I signed,” said Picton.

Picton said they weren’t given any opportunity that wasn’t provided to any other potential contractors.

“All the information that I received came from the city website,” said Picton. “That’s actually how I found it, I wasn’t notified as a councillor.”

Picton said he notified the other council members that his company planned to submit a proposal for the contract.

The situation isn’t an unusual one, according to Picton, who points out that in some communities, especially smaller ones, a council member may own the only local company able to handle the job.

“It’s a very common occurrence all across the province. We did it 100 per cent by the book on this one,” said Picton. “Any communications, any information we received was through the regular channels, like anybody that would apply through the RFP.”

The only exception to that, Picton said, was the voluntary walk-through that only his company attended.

“Any questions we asked were added in as the addendum to the RFP on the city web page,” said Picton, who confirmed that he did not approach city staff attempting to gain advantageous information. “After that, any communication was just straight through to procurement management.”

In her report to city council, corporate officer Dana Schmidt said the Community Charter does not prohibit a council member from having a contract with the municipality but it does require the council member disclose the information and possible conflict.

Only one other company chose to submit a proposal, Dynamic Landscaping and Renos from Castlegar. According to chief financial officer Jim Bauer, the three city staff that evaluated the proposals gave Picton’s company an average score of 91.07 points, and Dynamic Landscaping 79.54 points.

Sun-Oak’s proposal was slightly higher for the base contract, $186,999 versus $186,749 from Dynamic Landscaping. But Dynamic proposed $2.96 for the approximately 9,000 sandbags on private lands, making their total price about $7040 higher than Sun-Oak’s $206,348.99 total.

“The Sun-Oak proposal scored higher points primarily owing to a more thorough and well-defined approach to the proposal, and also its slightly lower overall cost,” wrote Bauer in a report. His assessment is the process was conducted fairly and objectively.

“In addition, the city will be retaining an external firm to conduct an independent review of the procurement process,” wrote Bauer.

The cost of the sandbag removal and disposal is expected to be covered by the province through Emergency Management B.C., but any costs not covered will be paid by the city.

Just Posted

Penticton bookkeeper may face jail time for embezzlement

Sentencing stances ranged from three years of probation to six months in jail for $60k embezzlement

Penticton Lakers lose to Kelowna Owls in basketball provincial qualifier

Junior girls basketball provincial qualifier held in Penticton

Public invited to bring Smart Cities Challenge ideas to ExpOCP

Penticton residents can offer ideas at event held on Jan. 18

Video: Physicians salute Penticton philanthropist

Physicians say philanthropist, David Kampe, “single-handedly” changed patient care quality

Regular offender gets three more weeks in jail

Richard Meier, who has been through the revolving door, stole a purse and spent $800 on credit cards

Video: Documentary features Okanagan ice climbing

First documentary for Penticton filmmaker captures elusive Okanagan ice climbing

Senior randomly stabbed in B.C. mall food court

Woman arrested after victim, 71, suffers serious injuries

B.C. Liberal hopefuls begin final leadership push

Five MLAs, one outsider pitch policies to party members

Vancouver Island marijuana producer bought by Aphria in $230M deal

Aphria’s annual production forecast increases to 230,000 kgs

Lawyer says RCMP cleared in car wash shooting

Independent report into shooting of Kayman Winter not yet released to the public.

UPDATED: ‘Young, innocent’ teen hit during Vancouver shootout dies

15-year-old Coquitlam boy was in a car driving by the scene

Ontario man charged with selling Canadian’s usernames and passwords

Ontario man ran site that peddled billions of pieces of personal data: RCMP

David Emerson quits lumber talks as legal action begins

Former federal minister served as B.C. softwood trade point man

Men accused in Michael Bonin’s murder knew him: IHIT

20-year-old’s body found on a rural service road North of Hope in April

Most Read