Summerland man facing 1-3 years for fight with neighbour

Joshua James Doell, facing one count of aggravated assault, is awaiting a judge’s decision

A Summerland man charged with aggravated assault will face 12 months to three years incarceration over a fight with his neighbour at the time involving a pruning knife.

Joshua James Doell has been on bail for over two years, since he was released on bail in December 2015, and was originally facing a charge of assault causing bodily harm along with the aggravated assault count.

Doell, 43, is looking at a pair of widely disparate sentences — Crown lawyer Kurt Froehlich is seeking two to three years for the assault, while defence lawyer Norm Yates suggested a period of 12 to 16 months in jail. Similarly, for a breach of probation, Crown suggested one to seven days, while the defence suggested just one day.

Related: Bail for man charged with assault

On April 13, Summerland RCMP received a call that a man had been assaulted by his neighbour, and upon arrival, police found Doell’s intoxicated neighbour with a one-inch cut on his forehead, dried blood on his nose, mouth and face and complaining of sore ribs.

The court heard Monday morning Doell and his neighbour were playing board games and drinking when the two got into a fight over a piece of furniture belonging to Doell’s neighbour.

During a December 2015 bail hearing, Froehlich said Doell had a “strong odour of liquor on his breath” upon police arrival, and “when he was read his charter rights, Mr. Doell plugged his ears and began singing.”

A broken rib, a fractured rib and fractured wrist were listed among the injuries sustained by the neighbour in the struggle, in which the two reportedly had struggled to graba hammer on the floor of the unit.

Related: Man arrested in connection with Summerland stabbing

“(The man) told police he had run into traffic, jumping in front of cars because he believed Mr. Doell was trying to kill him,” Froehlich told the court in December 2015.

A pruning knife was also involved in the altercation, the court heard.

“My understanding of the evidence in your decision was that Mr. Doell didn’t aggressively push the blade of the knife into his friend’s back,” Yates said. “The use of the knife was in the midst of an aggressive struggle and that when the knife was yielded and the complainant got cut.”

Yates claimed the knife was used to gain the upper hand in the fight and put an end to it, not to actually be used against his neighbour.

Related: Man charged with Summerland stabbing pleads not guilty

Froehlich suggested a number of aggravating factors in sentencing, particularly the effect he said the neighbour has sustained, both psychologically and physically, which he has still yet to recover from.

Doell was on bail at the time of the fight and has a past conviction, albeit after the April 2015 incident before the court Monday morning, for an assault.

Doell had admitted to drinking alcohol since being released on bail, something he was ordered against as a condition of release, and Froehlich also said a pre-sentence report suggested little effort on Doell’s part in an addictions program he completed.

“The other side of that is he passed. He attended and he successfully completed the program,” Yates responded.

But Yates said during his two-plus years of “strict” bail conditions he had not had any charges for breaches of bail conditions, although he was also facing sentencing for a breach for a probation order on an unrelated matter.

“You don’t need to sentence Mr. Doell to a sentence designed to protect the community from his volatile temper. What occurred was an incident, a nasty incident, between two friends,” Yates said.

“The incident took place between two friends that were much drunker than they ought to have been. And as I understood the evidence and your decision, the fight between them was not one that Mr. Doell instigated. In fact, he responded to provocation by his friend.”

Because Shaw was hearing a large number of matters on Monday, and the amount of case law for her to consider in sentencing, the matter has been deferred to the judicial case manager to determine a date for Shaw to announce her decision.


@dustinrgodfrey

dustin.godfrey@pentictonwesternnews.com

Like us on Facebook and follow us on Twitter.

Just Posted

‘Hero’ kid fighting cancer helping with B.C. Children’s Hospital fundraiser

Penticton’s Wills Hodgkinson helping raise funds for B.C. Children’s Hospital

Vees add another notch to the win column

The team beat the Surrey Eagles 4-1 in the Bauer BCHL Showcase on Sept. 20

50-site RV park proposed for Okanagan Falls

An applicant has requested the property area be rezoned to Commerical Tourist instead of Industrial

City council passes tax exemptions without discussion

Permissive tax exemptions approved for 2019

Watch out for Pavement Patty: Drivers warned outside B.C. elementary school

New survey reveals unsafe school zones during 2018 back-to-school week

Who’s running in Penticton’s election?

Candidates for the Penticton municipal and school board election

Update: Search called off for missing plane between Edmonton and Chilliwack

Search efforts were concentrated along the Highway 5 corridor between Valemount and Kamloops

Why Whistler for ski jumping in 2026? Calgary proposal gets pushback

Calgary 2026 proposes re-using the 2010 ski jumping venue Whistler for that sport and nordic

VIDEO: Hundreds line highway as family brings home body of B.C. teen

Northern B.C. showed their support by lining Hwy 16 as Jessica Patrick’s body returned to Smithers.

Despite progress, threat of 232 tariffs dominates NAFTA negotiations

Any deal is seen to require congressional approval before Dec. 1 to survive new Mexican government

B.C. MP Todd Doherty receives award for saving man who collapsed on a plane

Conservative MP was flying from Vancouver to Prince George, B.C., in June last year

Alleged border jumper from Oregon facing 2 charges after police chase in B.C.

Colin Patrick Wilson charged with dangerous operation of motor vehicle, flight from a peace officer

More than 35 B.C. mayors elected without contest

No other candidates for mayor in the upcoming local election in 22 per cent of B.C. cities

Most Read