Tensions flared at the Aug. 20 Penticton city council meeting during a discussion about the previously implemented economic investment zones bylaw and the decision to extend its sunset clause. (Google Maps image)

Tensions flare at Penticton city council over tax exemption bylaw extension

The economic investment zone bylaw was implemented in 2014 to promote growth in city’s downtown

Tensions flared at the Penticton city council meeting on Tuesday regarding the approval to extend the economic investment zone (EIZ) bylaw’s sunset clause, at the request of Wildstone Engineering & Construction after it faced project delays with its 48-unit building at 120 Ellis St.

According to a city staff report, the sitting council in 2014 had implemented the EIZ bylaw to “incentivize certain types of development in the downtown – including employment generators and residential dwelling units.” Under this bylaw, more than 19 projects were completed, equalling nearly $32 million in investment in the downtown.

Wildstone was issued a building permit prior to March 1, 2018, a requirement to qualify for the program which provides a tax exemption on the assessed value of the building for a 10-year period for individual strata unit owners. The previous sunset clause of the EIZ bylaw stipulates that developments must have had their occupancy permits issued no later than Dec. 31, 2019, a deadline Wildstone will miss due to weather delays and the local labour market.

With the extension of this clause to June 30, 2020, the 48 unit owners will split a benefit of $49,669.50 per year, totalling approximately $500,000 over the 10-year benefit period. During this time, owners will still pay tax on the underlying land, which is currently assessed at $802,000, equalling $2,961 per year. All taxes collected by the city on behalf of the hospital district, RDOS, school board, etc. are not included in the exemption.

Coun. Jake Kimberley expressed his frustrations with the previous council’s decision to implement the EIZ bylaw in the first place, a comment Coun. Judy Sentes said she resented as it was “not the time” to discuss the bylaw itself but just the extension. Sentes was an elected council member during 2014 when the bylaw passed into effect, as was current Coun. Katie Robinson, who also voiced her disapproval of the bylaw.

READ MORE: Penticton hires new economic development specialist

“Before I came onto council I was very outspoken about these EIZ zones and giving gifts of tax dollars to development. I was totally opposed to it, and I still support the concept that it is the wrong decision because it does not encourage development per-say. That only happens when there’s a market, and that will determine the development,” said Kimberley. “Tax exemptions do not create development. This is just a farce, the whole thing as I see it, truthfully, because in previous years we’ve never had to do this, and this council we’ve given away millions of dollars under this program, that 99 per cent of the taxpayers in this community have got to recover from. We’re giving it away literally.”

Mayor John Vassilaki also expressed that he was not in favour of the extension, and noted that the newly introduced Official Community Plan recommends no longer implementing EIZ bylaws. Coun. Julius Bloomfield voted in favour of the extension and reasoned that this incentive would greatly affect the unit owners and their budgets if it is not honoured by the city.

“I’m in favour of supporting this matter. My sympathies don’t lie with the developer, they put up their money and build something and take the chances, sometimes they make a lot of money and sometimes they don’t,” said Bloomfield. “But my concerns, in this case, are for the people buying into that development. We’ve got 25 to 30 sales in that building where people have budgeted with the deal that they thought they had, and some of them are young families … If we deny this, the benefits that we’re taking away are not from the developer, it’s those people that have bought in.”

READ MORE: South Okanagan real estate market continues to stabilize, Millennials eager to become homeowners

Coun. Campbell Watt also supported the extension because “it’s not a loss in tax revenue, it’s a delay in it” and he doesn’t want to see the project rushed to finish in three months to meet the deadline. Coun. Frank Regher was against the extension, using the example of a resident missing their tax filing deadline trying to negotiate with the government to receive an extension.

“I just think that our practices in bylaws should be followed, they’re not meant to be cancelled,” said Regher.

“I guess I just have a different opinion. I absolutely adhere to the philosophy that has been stated about bylaws, we put them in place for a specific reason and there are consequences when they’re not followed,” said Sentes. “But I see it as one of those times that council has the prerogative to look at the scenario and to address the request the developer brought forward. The whole point of the EIZ is being recognized by this development, and there have been some circumstances that have intruded with their completion date.”

To report a typo, email: editor@pentictonwesternnews.com.

Jordyn Thomson | Reporter
JordynThomson 
Send Jordyn Thomson an email.
Like the Western News on Facebook.
Follow us on Twitter.

Get local stories you won't find anywhere else right to your inbox.
Sign up here

Just Posted

Windows broken, racist graffiti left on Summerland home

Family says nothing like this has happened since they moved to Summerland in 1980s

Oliver cherry farm allowed to continue operating following positive COVID-19 cases

Interior Health not concerned about health risk to individuals consuming products from farm

Morning Start: Big Bertha is the oldest cow to ever live

Your morning start for Tuesday, July 14, 2020

Summerland approves solar project

Despite community opposition, council voted 4-3 for Cartwright Mountain location

Two positive COVID-19 cases at Oliver farm

The risk of exposure to the general public related to this farm is considered to be low

Sources say Canada, U.S. likely to extend mutual travel ban into late August

Prime Minister Justin Trudeau hinted at the possibility after a phone call with U.S. President

B.C. man who went by ‘Doctor Ray Gaglardi’ charged with sex assault of teenage boys

The man, 75, is accused of assaulting teenage boys he met through Coquitlam-area churches

B.C.’s potential deficit $12.5 billion as spending spikes, taxes drop

Finance Minister Carole James gives COVID-19 outlook

Rare comet NEOWISE and aurora lights captured in Okanagan

The image was captured over Big Horn Lake near Kelowna with a Pixel 4XL android phone

‘We know people are going to come to Kelowna’: Mayor addresses COVID-19 cluster

The mayor said people need to continue following the advice of the medical health officer, Dr. Bonnie Henry

City of Kelowna to hold funds for 2023 Memorial Cup bid

$135,000 of the city’s initial $225,000 commitment to the tournament will be held for a future bid

Vernon Search and Rescue aids injured Okanagan Rail Trail cyclist

Group’s Utility Terrain Vehicle proving to be a valuable asset on the popular trail

Hitchhiker with metal pipe prompts RCMP to close of Highway 1 near Salmon Arm

Police respond to report of man who pointed what was believed to be a rifle at passing driver

Canadians torn on scaling back COVID-19 benefits to save money: poll

Of those surveyed, 78 per cent said they were worried about the size of the deficit

Most Read