Editorial: It’s way too soon to start saying no

A boutique hotel in winery land is already starting to draw protests

The very idea of building a boutique hotel in an agricultural area, specifically next to a winery, has been public for just over a week and there is already a petition trying to stop it.

This is kind of sad, since the plans are still very conceptual, and the Hollers, who own Poplar Grove Winery, still have a great number of hoops to jump through to get there.

It’s also sad because when it’s complete, a new vineyard hotel stands to be a major addition to Penticton’s and the South Okanagan’s tourism profile.

Tony Holler doesn’t like the comparison to Tuscany — he says the South Okanagan needs to focus on promoting how great this area and its wines are, not looking to other wine regions.

But if you look at those other wine regions, you will find the kind of accommodations the Hollers hope to offer. From bed and breakfast to hotels, there are places for wine travellers to stay — allowing them the chance to visit the region, surrounded by the vines and wineries they came to experience.

So why not the South Okanagan? As a major wine-growing region, we should be offering this as a way for wine travellers to experience our region. And if the idea spreads to other wineries, great.

It’s unlikely to affect business at existing hotels. We think it’s more likely to draw more tourism to the area, expanding on one sector of tourism. The size of the accommodations would be naturally limited. This type of tourist more likely to be looking for intimate experiences.

Unlike the controversy over building a waterslide in Skaha Lake Park, this is not public land being leased to a developer; it’s private land that already has a home on it. Nor is it land that is being taken from the Agricultural Land Reserve. Only about a third of the land is ALR, and at this point, the Hollers are applying for an alternate use ruling, not removal.

Related: South Okanagan winery planning hotel expansion

Just Posted

City of Penticton park policy changes approved

The policy includes engagement with the community

Okanagan Medicinal Cannabis Conference coming to Penticton

A variety of topics presented by certified herbalists and a medical doctor

Penticton Indian Band ‘knocking on doors’ of feds for addictions relief

Penticton Indian Band will also focus on community efforts to alleviate overdose crisis locally

Vehicle fire quickly doused

Penticton Fire Department were dispatched to a vehicle fire

Injured mountain biker airlifted to hospital in Kelowna

A mountain biker spent the night with rescuers after suffering injuries

Unfiltered: IPAs explained with Cannery Brewing brewmaster

Checking out the new IPA created by Penticton brewery Cannery Brewing Company

Port of Prince Rupert names Shaun Stevenson as new CEO

Stevenson has worked for the port for 21 years as vice president of trade development

Senate officially passes Canada’s marijuana legalization bill

Bill C-45 now moves to royal assent, which is the final step in the legislative process

Fake attempted abduction not funny to B.C. neighbourhood residents

Two teenage boys won’t face criminal charges after scaring girl

Mosquitoes out in full force already? Blame the weather

But a B.C. mosquito expert says the heat wave will help keep the pests at bay

Man pleads not guilty in 1987 slayings of B.C. couple

William Talbott of SeaTac was arraigned Tuesday in Snohomish County Superior Court

New GOP plan: Hold kids longer at border – but with parents

Move would ease rules that limit how much time minors can be held with their parents

Without a big data strategy, Canadians at risk of being ‘data cows’

Presentation said artificial intelligence could give Facebook and Amazon even more power

Most Read