Editorial: Whose province is it anyway?

Time for B.C. to get a seat at the big kids’ table

There are manifold issues around the building of the Trans Mountain pipeline through B.C., but there is one that doesn’t seem to get discussed much.

Whose province is this? The federal government may have jurisdiction over certain areas, though when it comes to expensive ongoing items like health care and education, the feds aren’t all that involved. But the pipeline promises to pour quite a few dollars into federal coffers.

Alberta, of course, has no business forcing anything on B.C., though they stand to profit mightily from the pipeline.

This isn’t a question of whether a pipeline is a good or bad thing. The bitumen is going to pass through B.C. one way or another, as it is now, making its way to our ports for sale to the world market, and making rich multinational oil companies even richer, along with the Alberta and federal governments.

With the current B.C. government attempting to block the pipeline, the other parties involved have moved on to threats and intimidation: blocking transfer payments, boycotting wine and so on.

Wouldn’t it be better if all parties sat down instead and negotiated a deal that included B.C. as an equal partner? This province bears the greatest risk of environmental damage, on land and in our coastal waters, while realizing the least profit from the pipeline.

There is also the question of keeping profit in Canada. Instead of allowing this oil to be shipped overseas to be refined elsewhere, why not insist that it be refined in this province first at a new refinery, as B.C. businessman David Black (also the owner of this paper) has advocated for.

Shipping lighter fuel products would reduce the risk of environmental damage as well as keeping more jobs, and profit, in province.

But regardless of whether you are pro-pipeline or a protestor, moving forward because of threats and intimidation from other governments is no way to work.

Just Posted

Crews continuing to clear rock north of Summerland

Site has had no movement for the past eight days

Poll: How do you feel about the Trans Mountain Pipeline

The National Energy Board has come out with continued support of the pipeline

‘Incredible’ show to close out 2019 Penticton Peach Festival

New Jersey Jukebox: Tribute to the Jersey Boys and Frankie Valli & The Four Seasons to perform

Alleged Okanagan sex offender arrested in P.E.I.

Offences occurred while Ivan Glen Winchester was living in Summerland between 2006 and 2010

Music Rundown: Who you should be watching play live this week

Fill your calendar this week with these great shows

Girl heard saying ‘Help my Dad’ in suspicious radio message on Vancouver Island

Police asking for help following mysterious signals from somewhere between Comox and Sayward

Reports of rashes prompt closure of all Harrison Hot Springs pools

Public pool available after Fraser Health shut down all five mineral pools until further notice

No treatment for highly infectious measles, says doctor

10 cases of measles confirmed in Vancouver as of Friday

Two more measles cases confirmed in Vancouver

It brings the number of total cases within the city connected to the outbreak to ten

No gas in Okanagan town as lone station closed for renovations

Falkland’s Petro Canada will remain closed for renovations until March 1

Shuswap facility adds 60 long-term care beds

Mount Ida Mews hosts grand opening of second phase in Salmon Arm

UPDATE: One dead after crash on Highway 97A near Armstrong

Police have confirmed that one person is dead following an accident on Highway 97A Friday

Most Read