Penticton Western News letters to the editor.

Letter: National park will not damage property values

I trust that the Willowbrook residents will consider the facts more carefully

The best response to Mr. Knodel’s and other Willowbrook residents’ concerns (Penticton Western News, Dec. 13, Willowbrook resident shares thoughts on national park) about the national park reserve affecting their properties and way of life is those given by Parks Canada and the B.C. Ministry of Environment.

The lack of set boundaries is a function of the process of creating a park; broad concept (or what are called ‘soft’) boundaries are established, which may appear to include areas that really aren’t in. This is the case here: “Parks Canada (said) it does not include communities within new national park reserves,” a comment supported by the B.C. Ministry of Environment.

Also, “It should be noted that no boundaries or park concepts have been considered at this time,” said Parks Canada. “As we restart discussions, our area of interest will primarily focus on the areas that were the subject of previous consideration.”

Concerns that residents will not be allowed to keep pets or livestock without permits, along with guests have to pay fees to access their properties, not be able to have their volunteer fire department, not be able to change properties in any way, and be unable to move legally owned firearms through the park are similarly unfounded.

“The community of Willowbrook would not be within the national park reserve boundary, and as such local fire departments will continue to maintain their existing responsibilities,” Parks Canada said in its emailed response. “The local fire department will not be affected, so home insurance premiums should not be affected.”

“Area residents will not have to pay a fee to access their homes or to receive guests,” Parks Canada said. “Parks Canada does not include communities within new national park reserves.”

They also dispute the claims of park opponents that property owners would lose the right to keep pets, build additions or sell their property to people other than the government.

“The Government of Canada cannot expropriate private property in order to enlarge or establish a national park or national park reserve,” said Parks Canada, citing the Canada National Parks Act Section 15(6).

“Private lands would only ever be purchased on a willing-seller/willing-buyer basis, based on independent property appraisals,” Parks Canada said. “The federal government has no jurisdiction over property rights on privately owned land adjacent to the boundaries of a national park.”

Regarding firearms, Parks Canada also said …the law governing transportation of firearms — the Firearms Act — applies throughout Canada, including in national parks.

Mr. Knodel fears losing all local control over the park lands. Parks Canada now requires a local advisory committee for new parks.

I trust that the Willowbrook residents will consider the facts more carefully as the park process moves ahead. Far from damaging property values, experience around the world is that these are increased, not decreased, by being close to any protected area.

Eva Durance


Get local stories you won't find anywhere else right to your inbox.
Sign up here

Just Posted

Okanagan Search and Rescue teams add two dogs to active duty

Labrador retriever, Chase and german shepherd, Kaya are the new recruits

Okanagan College names two new board members

Andrea Alexander and JoAnn Fowler have been appointed for one-year terms to the board

Morning Start: Hawaiian Pizza is Canadian

Your morning start for Monday, Sept. 28, 2020

Three arrested after Keremeos shooting that severely injured one man

The victim was transported by air ambulance to a regional hospital

UPDATE: One dead after motorcycle collision on Highway 97 near Peachland

The collision closed Highway 97 off-and-on throughout Sunday afternoon

B.C. records 98 more COVID-19 cases, most in Lower Mainland

One new senior home outbreak, Surrey Memorial outbreak over

Editorial: Racism spans our shared history of pandemics

Guideline for naming of viruses designed to not offend cultural groups

Lake Country’s top paid employee retires

Deputy CAO moves up the ranks to fill the position

Okanagan woman shocked by return of letter in a bottle, after 31 years

‘I honestly didn’t think it would get past the beaver pond.’

Kelowna truck driver named ‘Highway Angel’

Donna Wright called 911 after stumbling upon a semi-truck rollover on Highway 1 in June

COLUMN: Examining the federal speech from the throne

MP Dan Albas raises concerns about the latest throne speech from the House of Commons

B.C. marriage annulled because husband was unable to have sex with wife

Husband did not disclose any sexual health concerns to his wife prior to marriage

White Rock’s namesake spray-painted with Black Lives Matter slogan

Vandalism occurred sometime between Friday and Saturday

Most Read