LETTERS: Fletcher is wrong

Fletcher takes an inaccurate hard line when he calls out the folks who worked for many years to protect the Great Bear coast.

Mr. Fletcher (Penticton Western News, Feb. 10, column Protesters fear peace in the forest) takes an inaccurate hard line when he calls out the folks who worked for many years to protect the Great Bear coast.

He attempts to minimize their role because they were “U.S. directed.” That’s misdirection in my book. We all take a necessary interest in what is happening on either side of the border. Our rivers, animals, mountains, plains, people and trade don’t stop at the 49th.

A reference to Greenpeace as “Dutch-based” is an attempt to besmirch that organization. Greenpeace started as a loosely knit group of primarily Canadian activists, many from Vancouver. Over the years Greenpeace evolved into a major environmental NGO with offices in over 40 countries with a co-ordinating body in Amsterdam. It’s important to remember we’re living on planet earth, an interrelated, shared system.

The variety and repetition of loaded terms and phrases, and not-so-subtle attacks on celebrities who speak out on environmental issues, felt intentionally divisive. If Charleston Heston supports the NRA or Clint Eastwood supports George Bush what’s the issue with Miley Cyrus speaking out on wolves?

Note that the wolves in question do make their home on the coastal margins in the Great Bear. Ian McAllister, a renowned wolf researcher has a book on the sea wolves, the same wolves featured in the September 2015 National Geographic.

Mr. Fletcher’s suggestion that Great Bear Rainforest activists used “bully tactics” is also an exaggeration. Considering that when this process started, three of the environmental negotiators were young women, I find it hard to imagine how they “bullied” corporate negotiators who were unfailingly male, 10 to 20 years older and hardened by the rough and tumble of the logging business.

As Jody Holmes, one of the core environmental negotiators, is quoted in the Vancouver Observer, “There was a level of trust that started getting built there — it’s discovering that the person across the table from you is just as human as you, they have most of the same basic concerns that you have, and they’re all really interested in doing the right thing too.” That’s the story.

For another perspective on how the agreement was achieved: check out this Vancouver Observer article http://www.nationalobserver.com/2016/02/12/news/rainforest-negotiator.

Dianne Bersea




Just Posted

Six inducted into BC Hockey Hall of Fame in Penticton

The 26th ceremony welcomed powerful figures both on and off the ice

Peach Classic Triathlon

While Penticton contemplates changes in the long-distance triathlon community with Ironman returning… Continue reading

Armchair Book Club: Delving into the threat of big tech

Heather Allen is a book reviewer for Black Press that lives in the Okanagan

Okanagan-Shuswap weather: Showers to start weekend, sun returning soon

Environment Canada forecasts rain on Saturday and the heat returning next week

UPDATE: Penticton resident’s dog found safe

Nicholas Bozak thanks the public for finding his 17 month old mastiff chow

July showers wash out half of the Okanagan’s cherry crop

Cherry growers say this is the worst season they’ve seen in decades

Canadian high school science courses behind on climate change, says UBC study

Researchers found performance on key areas varies by province and territory

COLUMN: Looking back to a time of optimism

The first lunar landing 50 years ago was a time to celebrate dreams and accomplishments

RCMP investigate two shootings in the Lower Mainland

Incidents happened in Surrey, with a victim being treated at Langley Memorial Hospital

CRA program to help poor file taxes yields noticeable bump in people helped

Extra money allows volunteer-driven clinics to operate year-round

Okanagan e-scooter company foils robberies

OGO Scooters staff helped return stolen property three times in 1st week of operations in Kelowna

Olympian brings women empowerment in sports to the Okanagan

Two-time medalist Natalie Spooner joined the Girls Rock the Rink event in Kelowna

Column: Understanding weather patterns a key to a successful garden

Columnist dives into Okanagan urban agriculture

Most Read