Study shows prison would hinder growth

Support for the proposed provincial prison in the Penticton area, and by Penticton council in particular, appears to be largely based on the belief it will provide substantial economic benefits.

A group of Washington State University researchers have cast serious doubt on this belief. Based on their 2004 analysis of 48 states, they concluded:

“We found no evidence that prison expansion has stimulated economic growth”; “We provide evidence that prison construction has actually impeded economic growth in those rural communities that were already growing at a slower pace”; and  “. . . counties without a prison have the highest annual rate of growth and those with a newly built prison grow at the slowest pace.”

That research concluded that “once a county or community is known as a prison town, discussion of other types of economic development often evaporates.” The research news release noted “strong evidence that seeking to benefit economically from prison construction can be an inherently risky proposition.”

A 2010 update by the WSU research team has added “that prison construction impedes economic growth in rural counties, especially in counties that lag behind in educational attainment.” In such counties they noted “a negative relationship between the growth of new prisons and growth in private employment.”

Their results, published in the March 2010 issue of Social Science Quarterly, concluded: “prisons do not solve the economic problems of rural areas but do create new ones”; “economic multipliers associated with prisons are extremely limited . . .”; and  “prisons may stigmatize host communities. Whatever (limited) gains are experienced as a result of the multiplier effect of prison jobs is always counterbalanced by the loss of businesses or people who leave or choose not to relocate in a prison town.”

These hard-hitting conclusions deserve attention, especially in the apparent absence of similar B.C. or Canadian studies. The U.S. definition of “rural county” appears relevant in Penticton and the South Okanagan which fit the criteria of less than 50,000 persons in an urban area and a total population of less than 100,000.

Our area also matches conclusions respecting local vulnerabilities — namely slow economic growth and educational attainment levels, which, while increasing, are historically lower than provincewide rates.

The above findings suggest that Penticton and the South Okanagan would be well advised to focus, as the researchers suggest, on “higher road economic development strategies that enhance employment prospects and quality of life . . . .” The Sustainable Building Technologies Centre at Okanagan College exemplifies one such strategy.

Denis O’Gorman

 

Penticton

 

 

Just Posted

Recovery centre operator said neighbours bought property ‘in haste’

Penticton addiction recovery centre plan halted by neighbours

Meningococcal disease outbreak declared in Okanagan

Five cases in last six months among 15-to-19 year-olds, including one in Coldstream

Crash blocks Channel Parkway

Northbound was completely blocked, while southbound traffic was reduced to single lane

Attempted carjacking at Penticton mall

A 24-year-old man is in custody, while a 37-year-old woman was uninjured by the incident

Fundraising effort for man assaulted at Penticton nightclub

A GoFundMe account was created to assist the Penticton man that was assaulted

Video: En’owkin project gets $20,000 boost

The En’owkin Centre on the Penticton Indian Reserve is working to restore culture and habitat

Debt-to-household-income ratio rises in third quarter

Total household credit market debt grew to $2.11 trillion in the third quarter

Charges in car wash shooting stalled

Court waits for police watchdog report on Salmon Arm incident.

Oz brings down the house

Laughter flies like house in a tornado at Cawston Players Wizard of Oz

B.C. Mountie told to resign after texting teenage sex assault victim

RCMP documents say Const. Brian Eden sent sexually inappropriate photos to 17-year-old girl

Family doctors should learn to treat addiction, not shun patients: scientist

B.C. Centre on Substance Use’s Dr. Evan Wood said efforts underway to change addiction medicine image

Four dog deaths investigated in Cranbrook

One vet suggests a parallel to these deaths and similar ones in 2016

Province rejects Ajax mine in Kamloops

KGHM Ajax had proposed a 1,700-hectare open-pit copper and gold mine, just southwest of Kamloops

Border officers rally at B.C.’s Peace Arch

CBSA employees tire of ‘lack of respect’

Most Read